English Writing Style: Oxford Comma and Strippers

,
oxford comma and strippers joke
Oxford comma and strippers. «With the Oxford comma: we invited the strippers, jfk, and stalin. Without the Oxford comma: we invited the strippers, jfk and stalin.»

I looked up wikipedia serial comma. There are arguments on both sides about ambiguity.

The serial comma (also known as the Oxford comma or Harvard comma, and sometimes referred to as the series comma) is the comma used immediately before a coordinating conjunction (usually and or or, and sometimes nor) preceding the final item in a list of three or more items. For example, a list of three countries can be punctuated as either “Portugal, Spain, and France” (with the serial comma) or as “Portugal, Spain and France” (without the serial comma).

Opinions vary among writers and editors on the usage or avoidance of the serial comma. In American English, the serial comma is standard usage in non-journalistic writing that follows the Chicago Manual of Style. Journalists, however, usually follow the AP Stylebook, which advises against it. It is used less often in British English, where it is standard usage to leave it out, with some notable exceptions such as Fowler's Modern English Usage. In many languages (e.g., French, German, Italian, Polish, Spanish), the serial comma is not the norm and may even go against punctuation rules. It may be recommended in many cases, however, to avoid ambiguity or to aid prosody.

I've always used the serial comma myself, because, in general, it is more consistent with the series of commas and less ambiguous.

Though, about few months ago, started to use this form instead: “we invited: {strippers, jfk, stalin}.”. This use of bracket i read about in wikipedia on curly bracket. Quote:

Curly brackets – also called braces (US) or squiggly brackets (UK, informally) are sometimes used in prose to indicate a series of equal choices: “Select your animal {goat, sheep, cow, horse} and follow me”.

I think this form is most logically simple and unambiguous.

In Chinese, there's a special punctuation comma symbol dedicated to this, called “enumeration comma” or “pause mark”. The symbol is this . It's Unicode name is IDEOGRAPHIC COMMA. See: Intro to Chinese Punctuation.

See also: On the Postposition of Conjunction in Penultimate Position of a Sequence.

blog comments powered by Disqus